Cytology grading adds to objectivity, reproducibility, and authenticity to the. Breast carcinoma malignancy grading by bloom richardson system vs. Excluded were cases where the aspirates were inconclusive due to low cellularity or there was only lumpectomy without axillary clearance. Comparison of cytological versus histopathological grading. Grading ductal carcinoma in situ dcis dcis is also graded on how abnormal the cancer cells look. Comparative evaluation of various cytomorphological grading. Grading systems in the cytological diagnosis of breast.
Research article a comparative and evaluative study of two. Breast cancer is one of the most common cancers in nigeria. Criteria for cytological grading of breast carcinoma a protocol for the cytological grading of duct carcinoma nos. Cytonuclear gradings in the breast carcinoma raise the level of fna reportage and improves patient management. Robinson grading system was found to be useful in grading breast carcinoma in fine needle aspirates. Critical appraisal of cytological nuclear grading in carcinoma of the breast and its correlation with erpr expression. Robinsons cytological grading on aspirates of breast. In some centres this is sometimes the only diagnostic procedure performed prior to definitive treatment. Cytological grading of breast carcinomaa feasible proposition. Cytological examination of breast fluids for cancer screening or diagnosis page 3 of 8 unitedhealthcare community plan medical policy effective 04012020 proprietary information of unitedhealthcare. Breast carcinoma is one of the leading causes of malignancy in females.
Pdf grading systems in the cytological diagnosis of breast. We obtained the clinical and demographic details from the. In this study we have analysed fine needle aspiration fna cytological material from 28 cases of mc of breast and correlated the cytomorphological features with histopathology. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma robinson 1995. Breast carcinoma, cytological grading, fine needle aspiration cytology. Because of the enhanced effects of new chemotherapeutic agents on the survival of patients with breast cancer, there has been an increased interest in the use of prognostic factors like lymph node status, tumor size, nuclear grade, steroid receptor content, tumor type and. Ages of the patients ranges from 25 to 83 years with a maximum number of patients were in 4049 years age group. Comparison of 3tier cytological grading systems for breast.
Twentynine dl samples were satisfactory for cytological examination. All the grading methods were developed for the most common type of breast cancer, that is, infiltrating duct carcinoma not otherwise specified type, and most of the workers used papanicolaoustained smears. With the increase in the awareness of breast cancer among women, cases of lump in the breast has increased in outpatient department. Prognostic role of robinson cytological grading system in breast. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma correlates well with histological grading and it may be useful in the prognostic evaluation of the cases without additional morbidity or expense to the patient. The details about various threetier cytological grading methods for human breast invasive ductal carcinoma are depicted in table 1. We obtained the clinical and demographic details from the patients medical records. Cytological characteristics of poorly differentiated carcinoma were as follows. Fnac smears were graded according to robinsons cytological grading system while the corresponding paraffin embedded histology. Breast carcinoma, cytological grading, fine needle aspiration cytology, histological grading introduction invasive breast cancer is the most common carcinoma in women, accounting for 23% of all cancers in women globally 1 and it is the leading cause of death in women 2 in india, data from various population based cancer registry suggest.
Pdf robinsons cytological grading on aspirates of breast. Aug 27, 2019 neoadjuvant therapy based on cytological grading has gained impetus, as it has aided in the appropriate selection of suitable therapeutic strategies 16, 17. Fine needle aspiration cytology of breast carcinoma international. Breast cancer is the second leading cause of cancer related deaths in females all over the world66.
Each variable is scored and the cumulative score used to assign a numerical grade of. The incidence of breast cancer in women is seen to increase in less developed regions. Corresponding histology sections were graded according. Cytological grading cg on aspirates of breast carcinoma is a useful tool for surgical maneuver and prognosis. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma is feasible and provides valuable prognostic information. In the robinsons grading system for breast carcinoma, six different cytological parameters, namely cell dissociation, cell size, cell uniformity, nucleolus, nuclear margin and nuclear chromatin, were used to grade the tumors. Fine needle aspiration preferred for benign appearing lesions, suspected recurrent disease diagn cytopathol 2008.
A grading system based on cytology would be helpful in the selection of patients for appropriate therapy. Objectives breast carcinoma is the second most common malignancy in women. The cytological grading system introduce by robinson et al. It is useful in diagnosing low grade breast malignancies, lesions with. Comparative analysis of six cytological grading systems in breast carcinoma shirish s chandanwale, neha mishra, supreet kaur, sourabh paranjape, aditi pandey, megha jha department of pathology, dr. Each of these features was assigned a score of 1 to 3 on a wet. An important prognostic factor pinkipandey, 1 alokdixit, 2 subratchandra, 3 andswarnkaur 4 department of pathology, u. Breast cytology teresa alasio, md october 20, 2010 2. Prognosis of invasive ductal carcinoma idc of breast is determined by anatomic extent of the disease as assessed by tumor size, nodal status and metastasis, and biologic markers such as histological grade, hormone receptor expression, her2 overexpression. Our information about pathology reports can help you understand details about your breast cancer.
Research communication validity of different cytological. Prognosis of invasive ductal carcinoma idc of breast is determined by anatomic extent of the disease as assessed by tumor size, nodal status and metastasis, and biologic markers such as histological grade, hormone receptor expression, her2 overexpression, andor. Prognostic role of robinson cytological grading system in breast cancer in correlation with the histological grading of. Of these, 27 were obtained from 24 breasts with cis. Breast cytopathology, also breast cytology, is a relatively small part of cytopathology, as core biopsies are more in style. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma robinson, ivan. An introduction to cytopathology is in the cytopathology article. Diagnostic fine needle aspiration fna smears taken from 100 patients with invasive breast carcinoma were studied without knowledge of the subsequent grade and type of the tumors. Pure mucinous carcinoma mc of the breast is a relatively uncommon variant of breast carcinoma with distinctive histological and cytological features. Department of pathology east carolina university school of medicine greenville, north carolina. The purpose of this study was to compare the cytological grading and typing with the histological grading and typing and the regional lymph node metastasis.
Breast cancer have doubled in india in the last two decades. Hidhaya fathima, k 20 cytological grading of ductal carcinoma of breast in fine needle aspirates and its correlation with histological grading. Comparative study of fine needle aspiration cytology and. Cytological correlates of axillary nodal involvement in. The aim of this study, therefore, was to devise such a system for grading. Grading systems in the cytological diagnosis of breast cancer. Fineneedle aspiration cytology plays a major role in the primary diagnosis of breast carcinoma. It is important to grade breast carcinomas, which will provide valuable information to the treating oncologists to plan their management. To evaluate various 3tier cytological grading systems and to determine the best possible system which is reliable and objective for use in routine practice. Cytological grading of mammary carcinoma provides useful information about prognosis. We propose that it be included in fnac reports of breast malignancies. Frontiers cytological grading of breast tumorsthe human. The grading of breast cancer on fineneedle aspiration help in understanding of the.
Preoperative assessment of prognostic factors in breast. Distinction between lowgrade papillary ca and other benign lesions can be difficult. The study was conducted in the department of surgical pathology, patliputra medical college and hospital, dhanbad. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma on fine needle. Comparative evaluation of six cytological grading systems in breast.
Grading systems in breast carcinoma with histological grading. The aim of our study was to assess the usefulness of cytological diagnosis for papillary lesions of the breast. A comparative and evaluative study of two cytological grading systems in breast carcinoma with histological grading. Cytological grading of ductal carcinoma of breast in fine needle aspirates and its correlation with histological grading. The diagnosis of breast carcinoma is often made by fine needle aspiration cytology. A total of 110 fineneedle aspiration cytology fnac cases of breast cancers were studied.
A comparative and evaluative study of two cytological grading. Neoadjuvant therapy based on cytological grading has gained impetus, as it has aided in the appropriate selection of suitable therapeutic strategies 16, 17. In developing countries where the use of fnab cytology has been increasing rapidly, breast lesions are one of the most common sites sampled by fnab. Cytology and histology grading of fifty breast carcinomas. This study has been carried out to compare correlation of robinsons cytological grading with modified bloom richardson grading system of infiltrating ductal carcinoma in. The grading of cancer is a histological method intended to help predict prognosis based on specific morphological features. Fine needle aspiration cytology fnac is the easy, quick and cost effective technique of evaluating breast lump. A total of 59 patients of breast carcinoma, aged 2857 years, were aspirated and the. The diagnosis of breast carcinoma can be reliably made by fine needle aspiration cytology fnac.
Cytological grading of breast carcinoma, diagnostic. Cytological grading of the smears can provide valuable prognostic information and aid in planning the management options. Comprehensive cytological grading of breast carcinoma was possible using robinsons cytological grading system with a good correlation with the histological grading. Using robinsons cg system, 14 cases were graded as grade i, 24 cases as grade ii and 12 cases as grade iii. Fine needle aspiration cytology fnac of the breast is widely used in the diagnosis of breast carcinoma. Among the 29 satisfactory dl samples, 10 34% showed mild atypia, 4 14% showed marked atypia, 15 52% were benign, and 0 0% showed cancer cells. Present study includes the information collated from each article regarding the architectural and cytological features studied on breast aspiration smears, the method, and criteria for objective scoring. These were graded according to robinsons and mouriquands. Prognostic utility of grading in cytological smears of breast. The technique of aspiration employed a 10 ml syringe and 23 gauge needle. In the present study, all the seven cytological grading systems correlated positively with the histological grading. Robinsons cytological grading rcg to correlate with elstons modified. All patients who were clinically suspected of having breast carcinoma were subjected to fnac of breast lump under aseptic precautions after explaining the procedure, its potential complications and taking written consent.
An endeavor was made to use cg on aspirates of breast carcinoma using robinsons grade and to correlate it with bloom richardsons histopathological grading. The present study was undertaken to correlate the cytohistological grading of invasive breast carcinomas and to assess the importance of grading. We differentiate on fnac between lobular carcinoma, ductal carcinoma of special types, and ductal carcinoma nos. Cytological grading of invasive ductal carcinoma breast st. Pdf the comparison between cytological and histological. Prognostic value of cytological grading of fineneedle. It typically is based on architectural or cytological features nuclear grade or number of mitoses, or in some cases, a combination of both. To evaluate various 3tier cytological grading systems and to determine the best possible system which is reliable and objective for use in. The cytological grade correlated well with the histological grading accuracy 62. Articles related to the different methods developed for breast carcinoma cytological grading were retrieved from the pubmed literature search.
Research article comparison of 3tier cytological grading. To clartify the grading of thyroid carcinoma on cytology, poorly differentiated and 17 well differentiated papillary carcinomas were investigated in the present study. The cancer cells look very different from normal cells and will probably grow and spread faster. Comparison of 3tier cytological grading systems for. In some centres this is sometimes the only diagnostic. Breast cytopathology, also breast cytology, is a relatively small part of cytopathology, as core biopsies are more in style this article deals only with breast cytopathology. Comparative analysis of six cytological grading systems in. Pdf cytological grading cg on aspirates of breast carcinoma is a useful tool for surgical maneuver and prognosis. Criteria for cytological grading of breast carcinoma a protocol for the cytological grading of duct carcinoma nos was developed by one of us gm. Grading is usually broken down into a spectrum from well differentiated grade 1 to the most poorly differentiated grade 3 or 4. Comparative evaluation of various cytomorphological. January 2017in countries with developed medical infrastructure, the use of breast fineneedle aspiration biopsy fnab cytology has had its share of challenges over the past 20 years, among them the use of core needle biopsies. Cytological grading of breast carcinoma cytological grading of breast carcinoma robinson, ivan.
Evaluation of breast neoplastic lesions by different. An ocular micrometer was used to study these morphological parameters. Cytological grading of ductal carcinoma of breast in fine. Evaluation of breast neoplastic lesions by different cytology. In the analysis of comparison measurement methods neither regression analysis nor correlation. The grade of an invasive carcinoma of the breast is calculated according to the nottingham modification of the bloom and richardson method. Cytological grading of breast cancers and comparative evaluation of.
The tumour grade is an important prognostic factor and is also. Prognostic utility of grading in cytological smears of. Comparative analysis of six cytological grading systems in breast. A cytological study on grading of papillary carcinoma of the. Breast cancer is the second most common cancer in females world wide accounting for about 1. However, robinson s method showed a better correlation and. Cytological grading must be routinely followed as a part of all fnac reports. Cytologic diagnosis and grading of ductal carcinoma in situ. New breast cancer prognostic factors identified by computer aided. The cytological grading of malignant neoplasms of the. Masters thesis, coimbatore medical college, coimbatore. Invasive lobular carcinoma, after ductal carcinoma, is the most frequent type of breast cancer and accounts for approximately 5% to 15% of cases. Cytological examination of breast fluids for cancer. In the analysis of comparison measurement methods neither regression analysis nor.
Cytological grading of breast carcinoma with histological. Comparison of cytological versus histopathological grading of. The present study, evaluated and compared the modified masoods cytology index mci with various other cytology grading. A comparative and evaluative study of two cytological. Grading usually done in histological samples for the selection of therapy but not in cytology. Introduction papillary carcinoma ca of the breast is a rare lesion, whereas papilloma accounts for approximately 10% of benign breast lesions. The cytological grading of malignant neoplasms of the breast. Cytological examination of breast fluids for cancer screening or diagnosis page 1 of 8.
Breast carcinoma is the most common malignancy among women worldwide and is also the leading cause of carcinoma death among women. Evaluation of traditional prognostic factors tumour grade. In the present study, a total number of 50 cases of breast carcinomas were included. The case for breast cytology increasing use of core needle biopsy cnb for breast lesions has led to diminished use of fna in recent years but. There are six novel cytological grading system used to grade breast carcinoma, being robinsons system, fischer system, mouriquands system, howells system, khans system and taniguchis system tables 69. Cytologic diagnosis and grading of ductal carcinoma in. The cytological grading of malignant neoplasms of the breast and its correlation with the histological grading. Our aim was to evaluate and compare two cytological grading methods robinsons and mouriquands in breast carcinoma and correlate it with nottingham modification of scarffbloomrichardson sbr histological grading. Eight worldwide articles proposing new methods of grading the cytological smears from breast cancers were published between 1980 and 2006.
271 524 831 481 1061 991 1155 1410 1012 1402 1556 1081 1215 509 238 949 139 913 1444 764 1452 167 1453 642 1362 873 3 307 1438 711 936 515 717